For a long time the foundations of an Ethic of Nursing have been formulated in terms of Christian charity. The article discusses this concept by examining the roots of modern Nursing in the Kaiserswerther Diakonie. This Christian work-ethic is criticised by modern nursing ethics. Instead of an Ethic of Charity an Ethic of Care is promoted by the common representatives of a modern ethics of nursing. But such as an Ethic of Christian Charity an Ethic of Care has to deal with those problems: the naturalizing of femininity, the asymmetry of persons in caring relations, the relation between justice and care, the relation between caring and nursing. Care ethics following Gilligan and her recipients are not able to solve these problems in a satisfactory way. Therefore it could be useful to reformulate the Christian notion of charity. It can be demonstrated that Agape is not combined which conceptions of subservience and self-denial. The difference between Eros as a perverted selfishness and Agape as selfless virtue can not be held any longer. Agape tends to reciprocity which has its model in the Golden Rule. In addition Agape is no sentiment, but related to action -Agape is practiced justice.

Enthalten in:
Zeitschrift für Evangelische Ethik; 2003/1 Kommentare, Studien, Berichte, Dokumentationen, Diskussionen, Rezensionen, Bibliographie (2003)

---

Serie / Reihe: Zeitschrift für Evangelische Ethik

Personen: Dallmann, Hans-Ulrich

Schlagwörter: Gerechtigkeit Ethik Nächstenliebe Beziehung Pflege Verständnis